Pepperidge Farm Remembers

Pepperidge Farm Remembers is the twenty-third episode of The Randomness Show, and the second episode of the third season. It was released on August 19, 2019, and stars John Manfredonia, Jack Hillebrecht and Tim Amalfitano. In this episode, John encounters a hyperactive fan, while reminiscing on old memories with Jack.

Plot
A hyperactive fan of The Randomness Show, Timmy, leaps from the bushes and runs to John - believing him to be Jack Hillebrecht, the series' creator. John explains that he's not Jack, but Timmy refuses to believe this, instead thinking that he's come back to revive The Randomness Show. John goes inside while Timmy waits in the bushes.

John finds Jack in the basement and sits by him. The two are on their phones for a short period of time, before John starts wrestling Jack - trying to recreate when they wrestled one another in a previous episode. Jack remarks that he hasn't thought about the series for years after his spiritual journey. Jack asks how their costars are, and John reveals Shrey was a robot who was killed by Apple, while the Unnamed Protagonist and Arthur Beansman died from "carbon dioxide poisoning". Jack says he's moved on from the show as he's going off to college, although he and John  look back at several old episodes for fun.

After Jack says his goodbyes, John goes back outside to Timmy, and explains that Jack doesn't want to continue The Randomness Show. The two are displeased by this, but Timmy thinks of a way to fix the situation.

Characters
Shrey and Ayush Pasricha appear through archival footage from the previous episode.
 * Jack Hillebrecht as Jack
 * John Manfredonia as John
 * Tim Amalfitano as Timmy